When Loyalty and Growth Diverge: Navigating Team Evolution in a Scaling Business
8:34
Every founder remembers the earliest days. Those lean months when trust, reliability, and loyalty outweighed credentials or perfect resumes. The real measure was simple: Who would say yes, who would lean in, and who would treat your fledgling business as if it were their own? For Pete, the answer was clear. He hired his friend’s mother, Doris, a tireless force who managed everything from bookkeeping to cleaning, working marathon hours so Pete could focus on building the company. Doris was the backbone, and Pete could not imagine his business without her.
As months became years, and the business matured, the demands shifted. Growth brought new complexity: specialized regulations, advanced accounting systems, evolving HR policies, and more sophisticated customer expectations. Despite Doris’s unwavering commitment, a growing gap emerged between what the company needed and what Doris could provide. No matter how many weekends she worked or how many extra hours she volunteered, she could not bridge that divide. The business had outgrown her capacity.
This moment arrives in nearly every entrepreneurial journey. The skills and loyalty that launch a company do not always match the requirements to scale it. Leaders often feel torn—loyalty to those who helped them survive versus responsibility to ensure the company thrives. The pain is real and rarely discussed openly. How do you tell a trusted team member, who has given everything, the business has moved beyond what they can deliver?
The Metiss Group has worked with founders and leadership teams for decades, witnessing the emotional and operational challenges that come with business inflection points. With deep experience in hiring best practices, executive leadership coaching, and aligning organizational structure with company goals, The Metiss Group understands both the human and business dimensions of growth. This article distills that expertise into practical guidance for founders facing the tough reality: what got you here, won’t get you there – and that often goes for your people, too.
This article will help founders recognize, address, and navigate these critical transitions—balancing empathy, loyalty, and strategic leadership. It examines not only what to do when a Doris has reached her ceiling, but how to do it with integrity, care, and a clear eye toward the company’s future.
The founder’s journey is uniquely personal, often marked by deep bonds forged in adversity. Early hires—friends, relatives, or trusted allies—are indispensable in the beginning. They carry the company through uncertainty, working beyond their job descriptions and investing themselves emotionally in the venture. As businesses mature, however, complexity increases exponentially. Accounting shifts from simple bookkeeping to rigorous financial management, HR policies move beyond basic compliance to sophisticated talent development, and operational needs demand expertise rather than generalist effort.
Founders like Pete face an inflection point: when loyalty alone cannot compensate for the evolving needs of a growing enterprise. Recognizing this moment requires a clear-eyed assessment of what the business truly needs. Leadership teams must analyze not only employee performance, but also the fit between current skills and future requirements. Employee performance reviews become a vital tool, not just for accountability, but for strategic alignment.
Understanding the Ceiling: The Peter Principle in Action
The “Peter Principle” describes a common organizational challenge: employees rise to their level of incompetence. In other words, loyal and capable team members eventually encounter roles or responsibilities that exceed their skill set. Doris’s story is a classic case. Her unmatched dedication and reliability were the foundation for early success, but as the company grew, her abilities did not scale with the increasing demands.
This principle is not a failure of character or work ethic. It is a recognition that growth outpaces individual capacity, especially when new competencies are required. Emotional intelligence in the workplace becomes critical. Leaders must distinguish between an employee’s loyalty and their effectiveness in a new context. IQ and EQ both matter, yet neither can replace specialized expertise when the business requires it.
Making Strategic Changes Without Losing Humanity
A founder’s greatest challenge is reconciling personal loyalty with the strategic imperatives of business growth. Accepting the company has outgrown original employees is difficult, but it is also necessary. This realization demands courage and compassion. Founders must approach these conversations with honesty, clarity, and empathy. Transparent communication about the company’s direction and the skills required to get there is essential.
Supporting team members through this transition requires action beyond mere acknowledgment. In some cases, training and leadership development programs can bridge the skills gap. Offering leadership and development classes or emotional intelligence training can empower employees like Doris to grow alongside the company. However, there are instances when even the best training cannot overcome a fundamental mismatch between the employee’s abilities and the company’s evolving needs.
Leveraging Professionals to Lead Business Evolution
Professionalizing the leadership team is often the next step in a company’s journey. Bringing in an Integrator for a company Running on EOS® or similar strategic leadership, professionals provides the expertise and structure necessary to sustain growth. These leaders are equipped to align teams, drive accountability, and foster a culture of performance that supports scaling. The role of an Integrator is not to replace early team members outright, but to elevate the organization’s capacity and support everyone’s best contribution.
Engaging executive leadership coaching and leadership training programs also supports both new and original employees, helping them adapt to changing expectations. These investments reinforce the message: growth benefits everyone—when it is managed with respect and intention.
Supporting Original Employees: Training, Repositioning, or Transition
Not every loyal employee can make the leap to a more complex, specialized organization. Founders must consider several options. Repositioning employees to roles where their strengths are best utilized is one approach. For example, a team member who thrives in operations but struggles with finance might shift to a position focused on logistics or facilities management.
When repositioning is not viable, supporting a dignified transition is crucial. Offering generous severance, personalized coaching, or assistance in finding a new role honors the contribution of those who helped build the foundation. Sometimes, emotional intelligence courses or leadership development camps can be part of an exit package, equipping employees for success elsewhere.
Leaders should remember: Growth is not a repudiation of loyalty. It is an acknowledgment both the company and its people are on journeys that sometimes diverge. By addressing these transitions with integrity and strategic foresight, founders set their organizations and their people up for long-term success.
Takeaways
The people who help launch a business are not always the same people who can help scale it. Recognizing when growth and loyalty diverge is a test of strategic leadership. By balancing empathy with clear-eyed assessment, leveraging professional expertise, and supporting employees through training or transition, founders can guide their companies and their people through growth’s toughest moments. The Metiss Group stands ready to support organizations as they navigate these essential leadership challenges, providing guidance, tools, and training to ensure every transition strengthens the company’s future.
Takeaways